Historic Survey Measures Social Connections and Civic Involvement in Silicon Valley

[Community Highlights] [Press Release] [Survey Highlights] [Report]

Embargoed for Release until 12:01 a.m. PST March 1, 2001
Contact: DEBBIE FORD-SCRIBA 650/581-4312 MICHELLE MCGURK 408/278-2208

Peninsula Community Foundation and Community Foundation Silicon Valley have joined with the Saguaro Seminar at the John F. Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University and colleagues in 40 communities around the country to measure how connected residents are to family, friends, neighbors and civic institutions on a local and national level.

"The Social Capital Benchmark Survey represents the most comprehensive effort in history to measure the degree of 'social glue' that binds us together as communities," said Peter Hero, president of Community Foundation Silicon Valley.

The survey measures everything from levels of giving blood, to hanging out with friends; from participating in various groups and associations to levels of trust; from participation in group arts and group sports to the diversity of friendship patterns.

"We hope that the survey results stimulate discussion about where the fabric of our community appears strong and where it may need bolstering," said Sterling Speirn, Peninsula Community Foundation president.

James L. Koch, director of the Center for Science, Technology, and Society (www.scu.edu/sts) and professor of management at Santa Clara University, served as academic advisor for the Social Capital Benchmark Survey. His report, "Building Community: Social Connections and Civic Involvement in Silicon Valley," which outlines preliminary findings revealed in the survey will be presented Tuesday, March 6 at a community forum at SCU.

"This study is all about us. Wonderfully rich soil exists here in Silicon Valley for building a world class community, but some of the collective action challenges that we face will only be solved if we are able to develop new institutional and collaborative mechanisms to augment the traditional underpinnings of social cohesion, " said Jim Koch. " I am hopeful that this study will be a catalyst for such developments".

Challenges indicated by the survey results include building community in a place where business and technology networks are strong, but the personal ties that bind us to each other and to our community are weak.

Social capital is unevenly distributed across education and income in the Peninsula/Silicon Valley region. College-educated residents were more involved in formal organizations (37 percent with medium/high levels of involvement vs. 16 percent for those with high-school education or less) and had much higher levels of 'social trust' (44 percent were "high" vs. 14 percent for those with high-school education or less).

Locally, residents with household incomes of less than $30,000 participated in less informal socializing than those with household incomes of $75,000 or more (18 percent vs. 31 percent), had a less diverse network of friends (24 percent vs. 64 percent), and had a lower incidence of formal group ties (15 percent vs. 36 percent). Similarly, connections increased as household income increased.

Despite the tremendous wealth amassed here in the past decade, the survey shows that residents give less of their time and resources to the community. The average respondent gave $1,355 per year and has a household income of $67,800. Nationally, the average family gave $1,516 per year and earned $53,000. Residents report volunteering about 6.9 times per year in Silicon Valley, compared with 9.5 nationally.

The region is remarkably diverse in the number and variety of religious communities with which residents identify, but overall residents are less involved in faith communities than in other parts of the country. Weekly religious services are attended by 27 percent of residents vs. 41 percent nationally, and 69 percent of local residents say that religion is very or somewhat important in their lives vs. 84 percent nationally.

The survey shows that 45 percent of local residents say there are obstacles that keep them from getting involved in the community (vs. 47 percent nationally). Of these residents, 56 percent say "a demanding work schedule or inadequate child care" is a very important obstacle (vs. 47 percent nationally).

While our social ties and community engagement are weak, we tend to trust each other-including people from other ethnic or life-style backgrounds. Overall social trust and inter-racial trust are higher here than in comparable communities. Peninsula and Silicon Valley residents have more diverse friendships by ethnicity and gender than the national average. 70 percent of residents have Hispanic-American friends vs. 49 percent nationally and 67 percent have Asian-American friends vs. 34 percent nationally, while 57 percent have African-American friends vs. 61 percent nationally. Residents report having a friend of a different race over or visiting their home 14.3 times in the past year vs. 11 times in the rest of the country. 47 percent of local residents have a gay friend, compared with 35 percent nationally. Even allowing for this diversity, friendships are less likely to cross income or education lines.
more

The Social Capital Community Benchmark Survey was designed by the Saguaro Seminar: Civic Engagement in America, a project at the John F. Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University. The principal investigator on this project was Prof. Robert D. Putnam, author of Bowling Alone: Collapse and Revival of the American
Community, and the survey drew upon the lessons learned from a Social Capital
Measurement Workshop held at Harvard University in October 1999. (A video news release featuring comments from Dr. Putnam is available, see coordinates below.)

The national survey of 3,000 respondents in 29 states was sponsored by the Kennedy School at Harvard University and is the largest scientific investigation of civic
engagement ever conducted in America. The local survey mirrored the national
questionnaire, and polled 1505 residents of Santa Clara, San Mateo, and southern Alameda (Fremont, Newark, and Union City) counties. The surveys were conducted by TNS Intersearch Corporation by telephone between July 2000 and November 2000.

National and local results are available on the Internet at www.cfsv.org/communitysurvey. The survey data, codebook, and survey instrument itself will be made available to researchers through the Roper Center & Institute for Social Inquiry in Storrs, Connecticut, as soon as possible after the release of the survey results.

Peninsula Community Foundation and Community Foundation Silicon Valley will host a community forum on Tuesday, March 6, from 7 - 9 a.m. at Santa Clara University's Benson Memorial Center to discuss the findings of the Social Capital Benchmark Survey and determine how the region can work together to build social capital. The program will include presentations by Mary Bitterman, President and CEO of KQED and Omowale Satterwhite, founder and executive director of the Community Development Institute in East Palo Alto.

For more information on the Social Capital Benchmark Survey or to schedule interviews, contact:

Debbie Ford-Scriba
Peninsula Community Foundation
650/581-4312

Michelle McGurk
Community Foundation Silicon Valley
408/278-2208

Kelly Shenefiel
Santa Clara University
408/554-5125

VIDEO NEWS RELEASE AVAILABLE
featuring comments from Dr. Robert D. Putnam of Harvard University

SATELLITE FEEDS
DATE: Thursday, March 1, 2001
TIME: 13:30-13:45 & 16:30-16:45 ET
SATELLITE/TRANSPONDER: Telstar 6, Transponder 12
SATELLITE TYPE: C Band
ORBITAL POSITION: 93 Degrees West
DOWNLINK POLARITY: Horizontal
DOWNLINK FREQUENCY: 3940
AUDIO: 6.2/6.8