In the Zone
Help for America’s Healing
A Look Back at Election 2000
First Person:
Freedom Is Not Free
Shorts
Public Service Celebration
Profiles:
Imani Duncan
Susan Fargo
Andrew Natsios

Photo: Mark Morell

A Look Back at Election 2000

She appeared before the television cameras only four times, but for five weeks at the close of election year 2000, Florida’s Secretary of State Katherine Harris MPA 1997 was almost as familiar to the American public as the candidates themselves.

The daughter of a prominent Florida political family,Harris had already served two terms as Florida’s state senator and was used to the rough and tumble of politics. But presidential election 2000, by almost any measure, was tougher than most.

Early on election night, the networks projected Democratic candidate Al Gore the victor in Florida. Hours later, the
projection was switched to Republican candidate George W. Bush, and finally in the early hours of Wednesday morning, the race was judged too close to call. With the national election hinging on Florida and its 25 electoral votes, Harris, responsible for administering and certifying the state’s presidential election, was on the hot seat and was given a lot of advice.

Colleagues told her she was in a “no-win” situation — a predicament, they said, that would more than likely end her political career. Some urged her to avoid the dilemma altogether and send the problem up to the Florida Supreme Court. But it was her husband, she said, who offered her the best advice. “When you were elected you swore an oath that you would uphold the law. You have to act with the most extreme integrity,” he told her.

And that, she says, is what she tried to do. But in the chaos of the ensuing five weeks, passions ran high, says Harris, and facts were often misconstrued — distortions, she says, that persist today. For example, one of her first actions when lawsuits began to proliferate, says Harris, was to ask the Florida Supreme Court to consolidate all of the cases in question and come up with a uniform standard for a manual recount. Her request was denied. Had the court accepted her request, Harris says, some of the subsequent confusion might have been avoided. “Actually, the Bush camp was incensed by my request,” says Harris, “but that was never reported.”

Harris says her decision to certify the election according to the statutory timetable was also misunderstood. The Supreme Court demanded she certify either Sunday, if her office was open, or Monday after the election. Harris was eager to certify, she says, not out of concern that the election would shift in Al Gore’s favor if she didn’t, she says, but because, until the election was certified, an election contest of the counts could not begin.

The contest was the only route under Florida law that Harris could choose. “What I was doing was protecting the
candidates’ legal rights — both candidates. I was following the law exactly. Had Al Gore’s campaign allowed us to
certify on time — within the week’s timeframe — he would have had time for the courts to declare a statewide recount. My certification in no way was meant to prevent a manual recount.”

Harris believes Gore was reluctant to have the election certified because he was estimating the American public would not have the patience to endure a contest in court. “But that proved to be false,” she says. “The American people were extremely resilient.” When Harris traveled outside the country during this period, she found the international community impressed by the United States.

“They were astonished at the exercise of democracy. The leader of the free world was at stake, and for 36 days, no tanks rolled in, no drop of blood was spilled, and we didn’t have a crisis of democracy or a threat to our constitution. We simply had a close race.”

Harris was also frustrated by reports that she deliberately halted the counting in Palm Beach County, when they had only two hours left to finish. “It just wasn’t true,” says Harris. “The reporting was so convoluted. Palm Beach was never ready,” she says. “They wouldn’t have been ready in two hours; they wouldn’t have been ready in two days. They were never able to unscramble the election results, so they sent their results in without any totals.” Since then, reporters who’ve heard her side, she says, have asked her why she didn’t speak out sooner. “They said ‘if only you’d come out more often, we wouldn’t have painted you as such a caricature.’”

But, looking back, she says, she wouldn’t do anything differently. “There’s nothing under the law that enabled me to do anything differently,” she insists. She spoke in front of the cameras only when it was extremely important for everyone to be on the same page, she says. Flanked by counsel, Harris appeared tense and reticent during those times. “I was only on television four times, but those appearances were played over and over,” says Harris. “Everyone thought I spoke so much more.”

Those few appearances, though, fueled a media frenzy that zeroed in on every nuance of her makeup and dress. “The personal attacks were over the top,” she says, recalling the attention she received. Harris believes that it was because she is a woman that the reporting fell to that level. Women still come up to her, she says, to say how appalled they are at how she was portrayed. “It goes with the territory,” says Harris, “that in this country, at this time, women are still treated this way.”

But there were funny moments too, she says. She recalls that her own personal turning point came in the final weeks of deliberations. During this period, she says, she wasn’t sleeping much — just a couple of hours a night. Awake one morning at 3 a.m., she and her secret service agent (she had received several threats on her life) trundled off to the only store open at that hour to do some Christmas shopping. When she pulled out her credit card to pay, the sales clerk looked at the card, then at her, and asked, “Are you Katherine Harris?” With everyone in line’s interest piqued, Harris replied, “Yes, but I have on only one layer of makeup. I’m travelling incognito tonight.” Everyone in line broke up, she said. “I don’t know where it came from in me,” she says. “It just erupted, but after that it was different.”

And for those who predicted her political career was over, Harris has no intention to let that happen. In November, she will run for Congress from her hometown district on the west coast of Florida, which includes her hometown of Sarasota County. She can hardly wait, she says, to begin campaigning — to go to the parks, fairs, and attend town meetings. Her platform, she says, will be based on the needs and concerns of the people she will be listening to during the course of her campaign. Soon she plans to return home on weekends, go door-to-door, and work hard to gain the confidence of the voters.

“I get to go home,” says Harris. “That means a lot to me. No one out-campaigns me. I really love working.”

— Sarah Abrams